From the September/October 2020 issue of Acoustic Guitar ; excerpted from the February 1995 issue of AG | By Linda Demmerle
Seven years after the death of folk guitarist Elizabeth Cotten, her music is heard everywhere—from Peter, Paul and Mary to the Grateful Dead to movie soundtracks and even the jukebox band on PBS’ Shining Time Station. Cotten, who began her public career at the age of 68, became a key figure in the folk revival of the ’60s, a National Heritage Fellow, and a Grammy-winning recording artist. Turning her instruments upside-down to play them left-handed—so that she played the treble strings with her thumb and the bass strings with her other fingers—she developed a truly distinctive guitar style and sound. Her song “Freight Train” [see full transcription in the July 2017 issue —ed.] is a fingerpicker’s classic, and her arrangements of tunes like “Oh, Babe, It Ain’t No Lie” are staples of the folk repertoire.
Elizabeth Cotten was born into the Nevilles family on January 5, probably in 1891, near Chapel Hill, North Carolina. Her parents couldn’t agree on a name, so she was called “Little Sis,” “Babe,” and “Shug” until her first day of school, when she announced that her name was Elizabeth. At the age of seven, she would steal into her brother’s room while he was at work and play his homemade banjo. Broken strings betrayed her borrowing, but even though her brother complained about it, he never scolded her or forbade her to play the instrument. Cotten tried to learn with the banjo restrung for a left-handed player but eventually returned to her upside-down method and proceeded to learn on her own. Later, she delighted her audiences with her standard declaration, “Nobody did teach me. Everything I know, I learned all by myself, so I give myself all the credit!”
Soon, Cotten’s brother grew up and left home, taking his banjo with him. Desperate to get her hands on an instrument, Cotten went door to door looking for work. She earned enough money to buy her first guitar, a Stella. “From that day on, nobody had no peace in that house,” she would say with a laugh. Cotten mastered the guitar and at the tender age of 12 composed her most famous song, “Freight Train.” Influenced by the guitarists of the time, traveling musicians, medicine shows, minstrel shows, and local musical styles, Cotten developed an extensive repertoire of standards, dance tunes, and rags. Her music included original compositions, instrumental and vocal tunes, and arrangements of others’ music.
Dana Klipp, her guitar accompanist in later years, explains, “Although influenced by others that she heard, Elizabeth herself was a true original source, going back to the turn of the century. She was a link to that authentic style. Being one of the discoveries during the folk boom of the 1950s, she was able to leave behind a great recorded document of her playing style.” Cotten’s music, he says, was “often labeled as blues but had more ragtime influence. . . . Her style of playing left-handed on a right-handed guitar was unique, producing a sound unlike anything a right-handed player could simulate. This technique gave her music a softer, almost classical sound. A combination of her unparalleled technique and her custom of using light strings contributed to her sound.”
Cotten married at 15 and eventually gave birth to her only child, Lillie. At this time in her life, Cotten added religious songs to her ever-increasing repertoire. The church was a great source of joy and comfort to her all of her life, but there was one hitch: The deacons of her church told her that she must give up her “worldly music.” After learning many church songs, as she called them, and finding that they were no substitute for the other music she loved, Cotten set aside her guitar aside for nearly 40 years.
Over the next few decades, Cotten often worked as a domestic in Chapel Hill, New York, and Washington, DC. Some time later, when she was earning her living selling dolls in Lansburgh’s [a chain of department stores in Washington, DC], she discovered a lost little girl, Peggy Seeger, and returned her to her mother, Ruth Crawford Seeger. In gratitude, Seeger offered Cotten the job that proved to be the turning point of her life. From 1945 until the early ’50s, Cotten kept her musical gifts to herself. Dana Klipp sets up the famous story:
“The Seegers were musicologists, and Ruth was already the author of a well-known children’s songbook. The older brother, Pete, was probably already heavily entrenched. Elizabeth, who hadn’t played music for years, picked up one of the guitars around the house.”
“Peggy was learning to play,” says Mike Seeger, “and it was Peggy who discovered Elizabeth playing.” Cotten was in the right place at the right time, with a house full of musicians on fire for folk music, and the Seegers swept “Libba” (the Seegers’ nickname for her) into their musical circle. As Klipp says, “She was the folklorist’s dream: a true, authentic musician.” Mike Seeger began recording Cotten in 1952 and produced her first album in 1957, now retitled Freight Train and Other North Carolina Folk Songs and Tunes. “Mike said that I was good enough to perform,” Cotten said in an interview, and in 1960, at the age of 68, her public career was launched. Cotten andSeeger performed their first concerts at Swarthmore College and went on to play clubs and festivals. When Seeger later played with the New Lost City Ramblers, Cotten traveled with them.
“Freight Train” had become famous—but for all the wrong reasons. Peggy Seeger had gone to England in the mid-’50s and was performing Cotten’s song. It was picked up and recorded by Nancy Whiskey, but credit for the song was taken by two men who persuaded Peggy to sing into their tape recorder. Confusion mounted when “Freight Train” became a hit in the United States for Rusty Draper. Cotten began hearing it on the radio and thought, “Hmmm.” “Pete heard it,” Mike Seeger says, “interested a publisher, there were lawyers . . . Elizabeth was given one-third of the credit for ‘Freight Train,’ which she graciously accepted. Later, Peter, Paul and Mary recorded it, and Peter Yarrow called and asked to give full credit for the song to Elizabeth, even though they had added something. That was very nice.”
In 1963, Cotten was on the bill at the first Philadelphia Folk Festival. From there, she played her own concerts, and in 1967, when she was in her mid-70s, she recorded Elizabeth Cotten, Volume 2: Shake Sugaree, followed by Volume 3: When I’m Gone. Cotten and Seeger continued to perform together, and at the age of 85, Cotten appeared with her family at the bicentennial activities in Washington, DC. In 1979, recordings of her concerts began to be compiled for Elizabeth Cotten Live!, which won the Grammy for Best Ethnic or Traditional Recording.
Cotten moved to Syracuse, New York, to be with her daughter, Lillie. Now in her 90s, her hands were becoming weak and she had trouble with the guitar. Klipp, a friend who was well acquainted with her style, began to play with her in 1984. Klipp had been arranging and composing with traditional folk artist Johnine Rankin, Cotten’s granddaughter, and eventually the three of them evolved into a trio. Dan Ward, coordinator of folk-art study for the cultural resource council in Syracuse, describes their work. “Elizabeth was very spontaneous and audience-sensitive. No matter what Elizabeth did, Klipp picked it up and carried it, sometimes songs that he’d never heard that she was remembering from her childhood.
“Her picking was a fairly distinctive style that caught on during the folk revival of the ’60s,” Ward adds. “Dana was not hired just as a musician. Translating her upside-down, left-handed playing, he was a second pair of hands to her and is probably the carrier of her guitar style.”
“I was an accompanist,” Klipp explains. “Most of the time she would be playing and I would softly play with her, just to strengthen the sound of the bass lines and give her some support.
Get stories like this in your inbox
“They were there to see her. They loved her, you know. She liked to talk to the audience, and they loved it. What impressed me was her gift of being able to project. It wasn’t just her music; it was her entire personality and her spirituality. It was a very gentle and graceful spirituality, although she did used to say, ‘You’d better get right with God.’
“She was pretty feisty, she had spirit; that’s what kept her going. Her hands became a problem but she wanted to play—she loved to play. She seemed to feel she owed it to her fans, although it was difficult to believe that people would make such a fuss over her—the fact that she was doing something that came so naturally for her and that she enjoyed doing. She was very unselfish about it. It would have been easier for her to stay home, you know. It’s not like there was anything left to do that she hadn’t already done.”
Cotten played her last Philadelphia Folk Festival in 1986 and her final concert, a tribute to her arranged by her peers at City College in Harlem, New York, on February 22, 1987. She died on June 29 of that same year.
“She was an inspiration,” Klipp says. “She endured and overcame hardships to share her music. Here, she had gone so many years and given music up when it was the one thing she loved to do in life the most. She suffered righteous indignation that she would play ‘that worldly music.’ I think she decided that if she was playing the music she loved to play, it was by no means sinful.” When asked if Cotten imparted any wisdom to him, Klipp laughs. “Yeah. She said, ‘If you’re up there playing, don’t ever stop. Even if you make a mistake, keep on goin’, ’cause no one will ever know!’”
Elizabeth “Libba” Cotten died on June 29, 1987, at 94.
This article originally appeared in the February 1995 issue of Acoustic Guitar magazine and was reprinted in the September/October 2020 issue.